The Senator & Scandal: Bob Menendez

Ryan Heshmati

September 29, 2023

Senator Bob Menendez, a Democrat from New Jersey, is no stranger to political scandal. In 2018, the Senate’s Ethics Committee wrote a “Letter of Admonition” to Senator Menendez on account of previous corruption allegations from a 2015 indictment. Those charges were dropped, but there are new ones. Menendez and his wife allegedly aided businessmen with ties to the Egyptian government in exchange for cash, gold, and nonexistent jobs, along with help acquiring a Mercedes Benz convertible for the senator's wife.

Investigators seized around $480,000 in cash from Menendez’s possession, in addition to over $100,000 in gold bars. Senator Menendez attempted to defend himself, claiming, “ For 30 years, I have withdrawn thousands of dollars in cash from my personal savings account, which I have kept for emergencies…” Regardless, the situation looks grim for the New Jersey senator's political future, with his approval rating at 35% according to a poll cited by Politico’s Mia McCarthy, which was taken before the indictment but after news of investigations, so it reasons to believe it may stand even lower today.

Senator Menendez refuses to resign despite calls from many Democrats for him to do so. Reuters notes that by September 26th, over half the Democrats in the Senate had done so. 

Although he may not want to leave office, the senator may be forced to, as Democratic Congressmen Andy Kim has announced his intention to challenge Senator Menendez for his seat. According to a Rolling Stones piece by Nikki McCann Ramirez, Kim stated of the Menendez scandal, “It felt like he was saying to me, to others, to the people in New Jersey that ‘I own this seat, this seat is mine.’ And that is just totally different than how I approach public service…” While the congressman may appear opportunistic to many, his criticism still stands. Should the allegations against Senator Menendez prove true, he will be responsible for a grave insult to the office of United States Senator, and the gravity of his wrongdoings will almost certainly forever destroy his legacy.

It is important to consider the tenant of the American system: innocent until proven guilty. Although there appear to be compelling links between Menendez and the allegations (namely the cash and gold), the legal system demands his presumption of innocence. Of course, the court of public opinion holds no such standard, and the damage may already be done. Regardless of how the scandal unfolds, the indictment of a sitting U.S. senator should never be looked at lightly.